by sciencejay » Tue Jan 24, 2017 9:29 pm
Holtmann is reasonable based upon Butler's tremendous performance so far and their pre-season expectations. He has gotten those guys to play together and play great, with important contributions from new faces. No doubt about it. Great job.
While I'm obviously not unbiased, I think McD deserves COY if we finish in the top two of the conference. Granted, that's a big IF at this time. With injuries costing significant time to two major players--one of them being the major influence and playmaker on the team who was in the hunt for all-american and conference player of the year (or at least first team all BEast)--and now an injury to another key player (Hegner), if we continue our success on the court, then McD is the guy. I have argued that the loss of Hanson (for over two months) was a bigger deal than was given due. JP has played great, but when he makes freshman mistakes like getting into foul trouble (Nova, X and Marquette--two of the three ended up losses), a guy like Hanson fills in with little drop off. Yet we are still 18-2 with the many great teams we've played and with those significant personnel losses.
No coach in the country has lost a guy this season who meant more to CU than Mo Watson. That is adversity with a capital A. You rally the troops and keep in the upper echelon of the BEast and the nation, you get COY.
Now I get that this is all academic. There's still a lot of basketball to be played. We'll see who earns it this year. Heck, if Nova continues its run, having gone all season without Phil Booth and living on about 7 players, JW will get mention as well. Even Mullin may get some love (KIDDING, Hooper! Stop typing that novela of arguments against that comment!)