GumbyDamnit! wrote:stever20 wrote:And once again- the tourney selection isn't based on Feb 26. It's based on March 15. Xavier is not a lock by any measure.
I have been screaming for 2 weeks that decisions are made at the end of the season and that I simply had faith that X and SJU had what it took to make the tourney. Now you agree that decisions are made in March and not Feb after explaining to everyone for 3 weeks who was and wasn't going to make it. You kept selling me on UCONN, Cincy, Tulsa and FL instead of SJU and X, who people on this board have a rooting interest in.
Any team that is currently ranked RPI 30 or higher would be in trouble if they lost 3 straight at this time of year. Why not just say X and every other team from RPI 29 to 55 can't afford to lose the rest of their games and expect to get a bid? Everyone would get that. Mich St might fit that description, or maybe GA or Okl St. But you single out X. Why? Because you have an agenda and you enjoy managing everyone's expectations on this board, every chance you get. X beats Cincy and Butler and your reaction: "uh oh Butler may drop to a 7-8 seed."
Whatever.
Bill Marsh wrote:
Yes, Steve, you are moving the goal posts:
Goal Post #1 - "like it or not, RPI is still a significant part of the selection process."
Even if the lose their last 3 games, Xavier projected RPI IS 48, good enough to put just about any team in. But when Xavier meets Goal Post #1, you introduce:
Goal Post #2 - "Regardless of the RPI, the committee will never give a bid to an 18-14 team."
Make Your Bones wrote:Do games on CBS (aka GT/SJ) have a "real" stream anywhere? Or am I just gonna have to watch on first row?
I know we hate on FSGo for crashing so much, but at LEAST Fox has an app for their sports broadcasts. Come on CBS!
stever20 wrote:GumbyDamnit! wrote:stever20 wrote:And once again- the tourney selection isn't based on Feb 26. It's based on March 15. Xavier is not a lock by any measure.
I have been screaming for 2 weeks that decisions are made at the end of the season and that I simply had faith that X and SJU had what it took to make the tourney. Now you agree that decisions are made in March and not Feb after explaining to everyone for 3 weeks who was and wasn't going to make it. You kept selling me on UCONN, Cincy, Tulsa and FL instead of SJU and X, who people on this board have a rooting interest in.
Any team that is currently ranked RPI 30 or higher would be in trouble if they lost 3 straight at this time of year. Why not just say X and every other team from RPI 29 to 55 can't afford to lose the rest of their games and expect to get a bid? Everyone would get that. Mich St might fit that description, or maybe GA or Okl St. But you single out X. Why? Because you have an agenda and you enjoy managing everyone's expectations on this board, every chance you get. X beats Cincy and Butler and your reaction: "uh oh Butler may drop to a 7-8 seed."
Whatever.
I have no problem saying what you are saying. But, folks then need to stop saying that a St John's win clinches 6 bids because it absolutely does not. I NEVER said that Xavier or St Johns wouldn't make the tournament- just they had a harder road to hoe than other programs.
As far as Butler's seed, you said that the injury wouldn't cause them to drop at all. They have dropped a seed line already, going from 19 down to 23 on Lunardi's S-Curve going into this weekend. They need wins to avoid dropping further.
Return to Big East basketball message board
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 30 guests